Thursday, March 22, 2007

Are parents a burden?

The Central Govt - proposed “Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Bill, 2007” comes up for hearing in the Lok Sabha this coming Tuesday. The bill proposes imprisonment of up to 3 months and Rs.5000 as fine for defaulters, i.e., those who fail to take care of their aged parents.

But will this deter people from ill-treating their parents or leaving them to fend for themselves in their old age? Physical punishments/torture is not known to have reformed too many people, no matter what the crime. Then how effective will this bill be?

No one can/must be forced to do something against their wishes. Things that are not done wilfully and from the heart will never do any good to anyone.

The case in point here is that if children are “forced” by the law to take care of their parents, some or many may do so just to abide by the law and not because of real love, care and affection towards their parents. Such forcible care will provide no pleasure either to the elders or the ones that are forced into providing it. A much better option would be for the old parent(s) to stay in an elders’ home or such similar setting than living like a dog in the so-called “care” of their children.

In today’s scenario, everyone faces extreme competition in every field and they have no time in their busy schedules for their aged parents. Still, we don’t hear them complain. A majority of them (our elders) try to keep themselves engaged playing with their grandchildren, listening to their favourite music or spending time with their spouse. But, for many, their parents are just like ‘ayahs’ – only that they come free of cost and will take good care of their child(ren). (I don’t intend to say that all are like that, but some definitely are.) Are such children actually taking care of their parents or using them to meet their own selfish ends?
It’ll do us all a lot of good to remember that “What goes around comes around”. Some years down the line, we all will face the same situations that our parents are facing today.

What our parents need in their old age is what we’ve got from them in our infancy and childhood – care, love, respect, understanding and a little bit of our time. I know it sounds clichéd but it’s true that all aged people, be it our parents or grandparents, crave only for a small amount of our time. At their age, money is hardly of any importance or priority in their lives.

Are they a burden on us? True, as some say, they may pass comments or advise us on our personal life. But this “personal life” is something they gave us, remember? Listen to your parents. If you don’t want, then don’t do everything as they say. This is a win-win for both – the parents are happy their child heard them out and for the child, he’s made his parents happy but can still choose his own path. (In case they are upset, then you can explain later as to why you didn’t do everything as they said).

A few simple questions to ask yourself - Can’t we do anything for 2 people who have given us everything, to whom we owe our birth, our very existence, our education, stature and life, and many more things that words cannot express? Can’t we even stand by them, love them, care for and support them in their hour of need? Only your conscience can answer this.

33 comments:

Neeraj said...

Maya, it makes me feel proud so read such views. It is easy to believe that such views have become archaic today but ur candid post makes us believe otherwise.

I love the way you've ended the post - "Only your conscience can answer this."

They say that silence is the arguement strongest to refute. While our elderly tolerate the pain - medical and emotional in the advanced stages of their life, most refuse to say even a word to their ungrateful kids. I will refrain from painting any particular generation to be bad because each generation has compulsions of its own and finally our behaviour is a function of what our conscience allows.

One point that I disagree with you on - ur view on the merit of financial compensation. Parents have every right to live their life in dignity and these 5K rupees however less, will certainly contribute for this.

Besides, one of the major problems most elderly people face is that of lonliness. the current initiative on Naana-naani parks is a step in the right direction.

Moreover, it may not be very "selfish" to children to expect their parents to care for their grandchildren. Look at the positives of this - the grandchildren are imbibed with family values that might not the case with an 'aayaah'. Also, it keeps the 3 generations closely knit together giving everyone a sense of emotional satisfaction.

Vivek said...

I have always felt that a person who finds himself or herself to be incompatible with his/her parents in their old age is unworthy of even the most basic of human respects. It is a deplorable thing that people need to be told, forget coerced, to respect their parents. This should be an instinctive emotion, arising out of basic human feelings.
Merely compelling people to 'tolerate' their aged parents will not suffice to alleviate the problem that one is trying to solve here. It has to come from within.

In the end, as you have said, it is a matter of conscience. Whether you have one or not is for you to decide.

Maya said...

@Neeraj:Hey,thanks for your views.Two clarifications:
What I meant was that a fine of 5k is not a way to punish the guilty and not that it should not be given as compensation to the elderly.
I completely agree that children may expect their parents to look after the grandchildren-out of love to them and not to use them.I,for one,have personally experienced the advantages of grandparents living with us.So,I'm definitely pro-the concept,provided you are doing it out of love and care for your parents and not just because they could still serve your selfish needs.

@Vivek:I agree with you on all aspects

Cheers!

Unknown said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Unknown said...

Finally a sensible post after long maya....worth my comment ;-p..I agree with ur views and neeraj's too..Its just tht parents can take more care of our children than aayahs can...along with care,the love and values u get,no aayaah can ever give...but truly said tht some children may have their parents with them just to look after their kids..i agree with tht too..but our elders feel happy and content looking after tht grandchildren whatever the motive of their children be...so still its a good idea...and abt forcing the children to take care of parents a indeed not the correct way....all in all a very good post..keep it up dear...keep writing such good ones..

aditya said...

A relationship carried on due to compulsion, coercion and obligation is lifeless. What is the point if there is no love, concern or affection?

I feel people get what they deserve. Parents are responsible for the way their kids turn out to be! Also, as long as grandparents are not exploited for their baby-sitting and nannying skills, but are "wanted", it will be a beautiful situation. It is indeed selfish, when kids' need for a "dignified ayyah" masquerades as filial affection. Also keeping the 3 generations together would end up being like a self-imposed captivity.

As the saying goes - "Be nice to your children, because thay are the ones who are going to decide your old age home!"


P.S. Kudos to Neeraj! For the first time in the history of blogging has someone been able to write a comment whose length exceeds that of the comment written by Reddy. (What a long sentence, Reddy I am getting your style I guess!). Even I tried quite hard this time, but I think I am second. Yippee! :)

Paromita said...

Dear Maya,
That was a very well thought-out article...
Actually the Bill passed is ridiculous in itself...
If children haven't taken care of their parents, what good will a fine of Rs. 5000 make to the children's or the parents' life??
Can any amount of fine, however big, heal the wounds which an ungrateful, uncaring child would have inflicted upon his/her parents in their old age???

The Govt. should think more practically and refrain from any such ridiculous means of punishing people...Human nature cannot be changed by mere punishment...It is better to provide senior citizens with better pension facilities and the like so that they can take care of themselves in case their children consider them a burden.

Although our parents love us very much, I'm sure they, too, have their own self-respect and would never even dream of living with children who would consider them a burden on their shoulders...

dashingkris said...

i Prefer keeping my comment short and sweet- Woh Baap hi kya jiski Beti na hoe, Woh relationship hi Kya jisme Pyaar na hoe! (Wat say, Adi!!! :) )

Anonymous said...

Maya,this time you have chosen that topic which is most near to my heart.
This article is not about focusing everyone's attention rather this contains the feelings that you,me and all of us have for our parents.

Whenever I read or hear the word "PARENTS",it really brings tears in my eyes,it always reminds me the golden time that I had spent with them under their protective shield and their immortal love.

Your article has reminded me,a short story of Lord 'Ganesha',It's like-
Once Lord Ganesha and his elder brother Lord Kartikay were asked to compete with each other.The competion was,"who can roam the whole world and come back first".Lord Kartikay started before Lord Ganesha and was very confident that he would definitely win the competion and on the contrary to this,Lord Ganesha was didn't even started,but after sometime,he gave a thought to himself and just took a round of his parents i.e. Lord Shiva
and Goddess Parvati and he won.

The moral of the story is that-
"Our life is the gift of our parents,Our birth,our upbringing has been done under them,hence our world is with them.It's all about loving your parents!"

Your article is trying to take out the emotions of those people who have forgotten their parents
because "Parent-Child" relationship is based upon sentiments and emotions.Keep on writing such articles which helps in developing emotional motivations. All the Best!

aditya said...

Maya, what wonders you have done. Not only have so many people commented, but look at the length of the comment. Clearly goes to show, that people haven't commented just for the heck of it.

Swapna said...

Nice one Maya!
Relationships cannot be forced upon ppl, nor can they be compensated.
Also i fail 2 understand the compulsions tht drive ppl away from taking up their responsibilities towards their parents.

kya baat hai Maya so many comments,all genuine :-)

the_jackal said...

Really gud post re mayo... Easily ur best.. :)

Its shameful, the way some of the elderly are treated by their own blood... One simply needs to go to an old age home in order to see misery in their eyes...One cannot fathom how some people can let their parents spend their last days in a place which is not home, let alone mistreat them....
it's really sad and i dont have words to express my disgust for such species..

Aarti Ramanan said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Aarti Ramanan said...

Hey, this is by far your best blog, Maya!

Well, I don't think there's anything wrong with the Bill. This does not compel children to keep their parents. If children feel they cannot keep their parents and if the parents too feel they would rather live at an old age home than being tortured by their children, well, its mutually agreed upon, all's well!

But the Bill will at least pose as an incentive for children to not ill-treat their parents, for fear of being dragged to court by them, and for being held in captivity for 3 months. Though no parent in this living world would do so!
At least it would ensure that the parents are living a dignified life with their children.
In fact I feel that the fine should have been around 30K or so. 5K is nothing these days. It should prick you when you are not able to reciprocate your parents' love, isn't it?

But its really sad to see that parents' love is coming at a price! That's sad!!!

Truly Maya, your blog has touched my heart...

Aarti Ramanan said...

Hey btw Maya,
i loved this tagline of yours against your blog name-Chatterbox :
'This blog is for pure timepass,entertainment & fun for me and all my friends... And in the midst of this enjoyment,if at all we gain any gyaan,it's purely unintentional and very much coincidental ;-))'
Must say, you write well...

Mahesh said...

Wow!! Maya , u r just getting better and better with each blog. ur topic selection is amazing!! Well, coming to the key point, i guess every person gets what he or she deserves. whatever good you do for people(children here) comes back to you. it's all karma. if you do good karma, u would have lovely children who would make you feel proud!! This bill doesn't seem to hold much significance. if at all children are not good to their parents, most of the parents would refrain from complaining. if at all they do, it would again end up becoming a case which would be dragged for years making it infeasible for both parties. and yes, i think you have to learn to be independent in life. It is one of the key things to be happy in life!!

Sunil Natraj said...

Aha... This is definitely one for the archives. I could wax eloquently, but would choose to limit to my superlatives to "Brilliant".

Anyways, I was just thinking on a few points here.

1: Why the bill first? Is India trying to wash itself off the burden that could be the aged. The fundamental question is whether we can handle an aging population in terms of healthcare. Our healthcare expenses are quite measly as compared to other countries. By passing this bill, the government can ensure that the onus doesnt lie with itself.

India should, and will have an aging population when we turn 60. The demographic dividend that we boast of, may become a demographic burden. As the population burgeons, its growth will reduce, thereby leading to a smaller employable population. This would put a huge strain on the children later.

I am in no way supporting the deserting child, but this is going to be an issue to the children of tomorrow.

Personally, parental care is a must. It will ensure that the fundamental reason for our growth today, the family, is not compromised.

And once again. Classic stuff.

Sunil Natraj said...

Continuing...
2: People can be difficult. Should abusive parents be allowed to claim damages. Think of alcoholics too.

3: Could this law be applicable to adopted parents?

Sunil Natraj said...

And finally, heres a great read.

http://www.rediff.com/money/2003/aug/25spec.htm

Aarti Ramanan said...

Hey Mahesh,
I do agree that you get what you do to others. But the value of 'Karma' is fast fading in this Kalyug! You cannot depend on people by doing good to them.
And moreover, the Bill would only help cutting a dragging case short!And talking about independent living, not all of the dependent population can fend for themselves by themselves!

Phani said...

Humne hamaari blog update kiya hoon

Mahesh said...

Hi Aarti,
Agreed that this is kalyug. But over here, we are not talking about a third person. we are talking about our children. if we bring them up responsibly , teaching them good values and be kind to them,there is a high probability that they would turn up to be fine kids.
Coming to the bill, it gives u a provision to file a case which was not the scenario earlier. and i guess everybody knows how much time it takes for a case to be settled in india. i agree that being independent is not an easy thing.but it's all in the mind. it's not impossible to be independent.
to@Maya: thanks bol...dekh maine tera comment count badaya.

Aarti Ramanan said...

Hey Mahesh,
People may bring up their children responsibly, but I meant that it need not be reciprocated always. There are other anti-social elements (read bad company/spouse) which create rifts between parents and children.

And agreed, cases mein tarikh-pe-tarikh hote hain, but nevertheless what's wrong with passing the Bill.

And if you feel living independently is not impossible, watch Baghban!!! :)

And Maya,
You owe us big-time!!!

Maya said...

Thanks everyone for your comments and compliments(Neeraj,Adi,Swapna,Raj,Aarti,Mahesh,Sunil)...

@Aarti: I agree with Mahesh.Karma does exist,no matter what 'yug' it is.

And this reminds me of what Adi said sometime back (his usual philosophy dose,you know):-
"When you help someone in need,someone else(may or may not be the one you helped) will definitely be there to help you".

Baghban doesn't depict that it is impossible to live independently.It just goes on to show that parents don't hold grudges against their grandchildren for the way they've been mistreated by their own children.

@Mahesh,Aarti: Please continue your debate.And haan dears,I really owe you big-time for this ;-))

Cheers,
Maya

Maya said...

@Surekha: Hmmm...worthy of your comment,eh? tujhe main baad mein dekh loongi...

@Poonam: This topic touched my heart too,that's why I wrote about it.

@Sunil: Adopted parents take as much efforts(sometimes more) to bring up their children,so why shouldn't they be taken care of too?
Abusive people are not worthy of being called 'parents',forget being taken care of.
Will read the article you suggested asap :-)

Tahnks again guys,
Maya

Mahesh said...

Hi Aarti,
hmmn..i said there is a high probability of children turning up to be good kids..i never said they would always turn up to be good..and yeah, if u are not good to your children, don't expect them to be good to you..
and baghban mein amitabh becomes a big time novelist in the end and it's his children who run after him..
i am loving this ..lagey raho..
@Maya..ab next time bombay aaonga, to kobes mein treat chaiye mujhe

@Adi..pata hai tu mujhe man hi man bahut gaali deta hoga ..kya karoon..control nahin hota..

aditya said...

Mahesh $&*^&(#@*!!,

I don't expect anything better from you!!! As i said before, I reiterate, you are a disgrace to mankind. Door ho jaa mere blogs ke comments se! Aur man hi man kya, main toh khullam khulla tereko gaali de raha hoon. What about the pretence - "Abbe mujhe bahut kaam hai, ek second bhi nahin milta hai!"? Hope u are still at it. Well u do do it well, itne time se sabko banate jo aa raha hai! Anyway, don't respond to this - coz U are too busy, it seems Infosys' stock took a beating because u came to Mumbai for 3 days. So, henceforth pls, pls don't waste u precious moments!!! The whole nation is banking on you.

Aarti Ramanan said...

Abbey, tum logon ko kaam nahi hai kya? Retailiating on every comment!!!
Mahesh, I'll give you a full dose on Baghban later. Offline mil mujhe, dekh loongi.
And what's cooking up between you and Adi. Do tell me, I wanna join in. I don't want to miss any chance of giving gaalis to both of you...

Mahesh said...

@adi..i coulldn't help posting a reply to you..tere blogs se to door hi bhagne wala hoon..ya to maya ka topic churata hai ya kisi book se quotes utatha hai..be a little original and then expect people to post a comment. and rahi baat of me being busy, then i am busy and am not a liar like you. i am a little free since the last two days and so thought ki tere churaye hue, uthaye hue blogs pe comment karoon.

@aarti--agar group ke bacche gaali dene lage to group ke badon ka reputation pe daag lag jayega..isliye shut up an don't ever think of giving gaalis to anybody.

Sunil Natraj said...

Typical comps class fare being dished out. Chatting has begun even on blogs. :P

The Devil's Paradise....... said...

maya.. me started blogging... hum hdnay honge agar aapke comments humare blog mein ho......
http://intendedpun.blogspot.com/


-- shreedhar

Vivek said...

31 comments. Most admirable. I struggle to get even double digit comments and you get thrice that number! Bravo!

The Devil's Paradise....... said...

tring*,..... tring*.... new post!